Eradicating the Dummy


In March last year, I wrote a post about my choice to allow my son to use a dummy titled “Am I a Dummy…for using a Dummy?” Little L wasn’t even two and I was beginning to think about when we would eradicate the dummy from our lives altogether.


Being the great procrastinator that I am, every birthday or holiday gave me a reason not to get rid.

  • Second birthday – we’re going to Australia in the summer and need it to keep him quiet on the plane.
  • Christmas – He’s not ready it/t’s not causing him any harm/we’re going to be potty training.
  • Easter Holidays – Let’s wait till he’s 3.
  • Third Birthday – Let’s wait till the Summer holidays incase I have sleepless nights.

I actually read a post by a blogger friend, Carly from Bungalow Burn, who wrote about her trip to the dentist with her daughter and the impact the dummy had on her teeth. You can read about it here. Her post made me determined to say “bye bye” to the dummy!

Screen Shot 2017-07-25 at 11.42.22

I know there are people who get fed up with novelty aspects of a child’s life that seem to be developing more and more such as Elf on a Shelf but I firmly believe that you have to embrace the magic and what works for you and your children. My son has a lovely imagination which I want to encourage, plus I love anything magical or creative so I began to plant seeds with my son regarding him giving it up…and the Dummy Fairy (DF) was born in the Roversi household. Our DF took the dummies in the dead of night to give to little babies who needed them more than my son. He seemed okay about the prospect of giving them up, especially when I mentioned there was a present involved.

This is what I did:

  1. Took my son shopping to pick his present that he would get off the DF. I told him that I would send the present to her and she would only give it to him once he handed his dummies over. IMG_6866
  2. Made sure that the present was something fairly decent so he didn’t want to give it back when he wanted his dummy. I was looking for an offer/bargain on something that was big but didn’t cost a fortune. We managed to find a Jungle Run Thomas theTank Engine track in The Entertainer that should have been £25 and was £15 which was my budget.
  3. Let him collect his dummies from around the house. It became aIMG_6869 treasure hunt and he loved finding them…even the dusty ones that had been sat under his bed for months!
  4. It was L’s idea to leave a cup of milk and a biscuit out for the DF. I reckon he was trying to bribe her…or thought she was like Santa.
  5. Chuck the dummies. It was important that I threw the dummies away in the wheelie bin ratheIMG_6862r than hide them away so avoid the chance to give in and give him one if he was struggling to settle or very upset.
  6. Wrote a letter from the Dummy Fairy, ensuring I used words like “kind”, “proud” and “big boy”. Every child  loves praise and I like to think the letter added to our sons imagination and making it all more real. (If you’d like to use the letter, I’m happy for you to steal it!)

As with anything child related, since I was pregnant I have always expected the worst then anything else was a bonus! I’m quite thankful that, after four nights, our little man has done us proud and handled it all quite well. I knew his biggest struggle was going to be settling himself to sleep and I wasn’t wrong. On the first night it took an hour for him to go to sleep and in that hour I got:

“Mummy I need a wee!” (I took him.)

“Mummy I want some milk like the Dummy Fairy!” (I got him some.)

“Mummy I want some more milk!” (I refused)

“Mummy PLEASE can I have some more milk?” (Me: shouting from downstairs “NO!” L: “Okay”)

“Mummy, I need you.” (My response was to talk over the monitor. He couldn’t tell me why he needed me, he just did.)

And finally, crying. I chose to ignore the crying. It wasn’t real crying and we have a no communication rule at bedtime so he knows he won’t get anything from me once he’s going to bed: no play, no conversation! I was right to ignore as ten minutes late he was sleeping soundly. Since that night, we have had no shouting or crying and the time it’s took him to settle has gone from an hour to 20 minutes last night.

One of the things I didn’t expect when our little man gave up the dummy was how grown up he’d seem to me. At three years old. I’m so proud of the little boy he is becoming but he’s definitely not my little baby anymore. He’s kind, thoughtful, loving, cheeky, imaginative and now, dummy free! What a little star!


As for my original post from last year, Am I a Dummy…for using a Dummy?, no I’m not. It’s provided a lot of comfort for my son over the years and helped us out in situations where we needed him calm and settled. Now he’s at a age where he understands more and is able to settle himself in other ways. He falls asleep with his teddy or taggie blanket and doesn’t sucks thumb or finger, which for a thumb sucking Mummy, i really didn’t want for my son. I know how hard it is to stop and taking the dummy away was much easier. Will I use dummies with the new baby? If I need to, of course! 

How did you get rid of the dummy from your child? Do you have any tips for those about to “ditch the dummy”? Does your child suck their thumb? I’d love to hear your thoughts. Comment below or on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram.



Mudpie Fridays

About Becky Roversi

Previously the writer of Educating Roversi, Becka is a 30 something Mum to two and has an addiction to mugs, Disney, pyjamas & stationery. Welcome to the Bubble!
This entry was posted in All Posts, Parenting. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Eradicating the Dummy

  1. JakiJellz says:

    Good old Dummy Fairy! We had one in our house too! They’re a god send too! Thanks so much for linking up to #TriumphantTales – hope to see you again on Tuesday!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Sadie says:

    Well done for ditching them, I love your idea! I thought we’d have a hell of a time getting my middle son off the dummy (oldest never had one), but it was actually ok. We started by having a rule that he was only to have them at bed or nap (haha) time, which took a while to stick as he’d hidden loads around the house and would randomly have one in his mouth that he’d found during the day! But then after a while of it only being for sleep, I think we just gradually binned them and he lost interest anyway. I was prepared to use Santa though (ie you leave them for Santa in return for an extra special gift), but it never came to that. We’ve just started using them with our new baby, and I hope he’s as easy to get off them when the time comes.


  3. Kitty says:

    I think parents stress a lot over stuff that works itself out In the end.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I used a dummy with my first. She got bored after six months. I tried and tried with my second but she just wouldn’t take one. She sucks her thumb instead. I think dummies are great and mums shouldn’t feel guilty about using them. They help to soothe overtired babies and keep mummies sane. Great post x #bloggerclubuk

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Becky says:

    Well done Little L and well done Mummy! So creative! I didn’t give a dummy and now I have a thumb sucker!! Now who’s the dummy? 😦

    Liked by 1 person

Let me know what you think and leave a reply!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s